CARTOGRAPHIC USERS ADVISORY
COUNCIL (CUAC) 2000 MEETING MINUTES
4 & 5, 2000
Cartographic User Advisory Council met on May 4 - 5, 2000 in Silver Spring, Maryland.
The meeting was hosted by NOAA. The CUAC representatives in attendance
were: Janet Collins, Western Washington University (WAML), Donna Koepp,
University of Kansas (GODORT), Clara McLeod, Washington University (GIS),
Dan Seldin, Indiana University (NACIS), Richard Spohn, University of
Cincinnati (GIS), Paul Stout, Ball State University (NACIS), Christopher JJ
Thiry, Colorado School of Mines (WAML), and Mark Thomas, Duke University
presenters were: Robin Haun-Mohamed (GPO), Vi Moorhouse (Map
cataloger at the GPO), Fred Anderson and Howard Danley (NOAA), John Hebert
(Chief of LC G&M), Jim Lusby (NIMA), Robert Marx and Tim Trainor
Mueller (USGS), Betsy Banas (USFS), and Tom Patterson (NPS). The official
Printing Office (GPO)
Haun-Mohamed of the Government Printing Office (GPO) told the Council that
GPO will distribute 28.2 million items in Fiscal Year 2000. GPO distributed
382,000 maps in FY 1999. GPO is entering its fifth year of transition from
paper to electronic items. The amount of fiche, paper, and CD-ROMs is down.
GPO is attempting to eliminate multiple-formatted products, but these are
reviewed on a case-by-case basis. The DRGs are available on-line through Microsoft
Terraserver. The topos are available on-line via TopoZone (www.topozone.com).
reported that in March she had met with representatives of the Bureau of
the Census. They discussed the responsibility for long-term access to
Census electronic products. Currently, these products are using Acrobat or
Hewlett Packard Graphics Language (HPGL).
Wetlands fiche and new web site were discussed. The revised and improved
National Wetlands Maps that had been done for GPO a couple of years ago
were formatted wrong by the vender, and thus not distributed. Council
indicated that if they could be made available on the web, they would not
need to be photographed again. Similar versions are available on the web
asked the Council a series of questions: 1) What is the impact on libraries
when mapping is online? 2) How do we use online spatial/cartographic data?
3) Do we download things, save things, archive them, or do we go back to
the original source material each time? 4) Do we handle electronic map
needs in the library or do we send our users someplace else? 5) Do we use
the airport charts, obstruction charts, approach charts, etc.? 6) What will
be the impact if the USGS Open File Reports go online only?
members each in turned answered as many of these questions as applied to
Printing Office (GPO) Map Cataloging
Moorehouse from the GPO Cataloging Unit made a few comments to the Council.
She said that there are over 200 map libraries, of which an estimated 40%
are run by professional map people. GPO is concerned about the remaining
60%. Vi expressed a desire that the map library community would provide
guidance to those who are uninitiated in map cataloging.
the Council that their map cataloging backlog is "almost nil." At
this point, USGS topos are being cataloged using two different dating
methods. One is in the edition statement. If the edition statement is not
available, the date is added at the end of the title. The Forest
Service-USGS maps are being listed under I 19:81 instead of A13.28. She
also indicated that USGS is very receptive to requests to place something
online, such as Open File Reports.
discussed a problem with encoding of GPO’s new BIBCO records. BIBCO
requires that the encoding level in the fixed fields be left blank (like
LC). The result is that records are being displayed in OCLC as LC
originated, instead of GPO. Thus, it is not possible to identify GPO/BIBCO
records in the OCLC title index listings.
National Ocean Service (NOS)
National Ocean Service (NOS) was represented by Fred Anderson, the Deputy
Director of the Office of Aeronautical Charting and Cartography, and Howard
Danley, the Deputy Chief the Navigational Services Division of the Office
of Coast Survey.
reported that Aeronautical Charting and Cartography (AC&C) will be
moving to the Federal Aviation Administration on October 1, 2000. They will stay in
their current facilities in Silver
AC&C prints and distributes NOAA and NIMA charts to the public.
Aeronautical charts will remain in the Federal Depository Library Program.
Libraries should contact AC&C’s Distribution Office in Riverdale, Maryland
for catalogs and other promotional information to give to patrons. The FAA
has not made a decision about AC&C printing and distributing Nautical
Charts. Fred noted that the printing of aeronautical and nautical charts
fit together well. There is a 28-day cycle for aeronautical charts and the
nautical charts fill in the printing gaps. The distribution computer system
has been fine-tuned and AC&C can start shipping aeronautical and nautical
charts directly to the depository libraries, rather than going through GPO.
The libraries should be getting these products faster--before the effective
date of the charts. For future digital aeronautical charts, AC&C does
not want to use copyright or user fees. They want to avoid a CRADA because
that would create a monopoly and would be outside the Federal Depository
Danley reported that they don’t know what will happen with printing
and distribution of nautical charts when AC&C goes to the FAA. They
have a Cooperative Research & Development Agreement (CRADA) for print
on demand for nautical charts. Nautical charts have a life of 1-2 years.
Commercial ships have to keep their charts corrected by hand from updates
that are published in Notices to Mariners. Until 1969, the charts in
the warehouse were hand corrected until shipped. Nautical charting agencies
in the rest of the world still hand-correct the charts before shipping.
Print-on-demand will allow more up-to-date charts to be distributed. A
print-on-demand trial of forty charts of the New York Harbor
area will be undertaken by a company called Vomela in St. Paul, Minnesota.
There is a continual update of the digital files and the base information
can be changed in two to three weeks. The print-on-demand copies would have
an added value and cost more. They could be produced in custom editions
with special marginal information for commercial users or recreational
users. They could be printed with or without Loran. NOS wants to test the
viability of these higher cost charts.
raster digital nautical charts are produced under a CRADA with Maptech. The
company has a web site, www.maptech.com which has views
of the charts available online. The regular CD-ROMs cost about $200 each.
They have a Professional Series CD for $500 each. These come with an e-mail
update service. Updates are received by e-mail and the charts are updated
when the CD is run. The updated charts can be saved to the hard disk or a
floppy disk or only the updates are saved so that the updated charts are
displayed on the screen when it is called up. NOS is working to have these
Professional Series CD charts certified by the Coast Guard for the carriage
requirements for use in navigation for ships of more than 1600 tons.
nautical charts are being developed by NOS. By the end of the year, vector
charts of the 40 largest United
States ports should be available. Ships
should be able to navigate using the vector charts with GPS. NOS has a demo
of the area near Valdez
Alaska. Had these charts been
available, the Exxon Valdez would have received six audio warnings before
it ran aground. The NOS home page has images of the nautical charts at 100
dpi. These should be small enough so they cannot be used for navigation,
but provide customers with an idea of coverage.
NOS will continue with both print-on-demand and lithographic copies in
parallel. When the price of the print-on-demand copies comes down, maybe
the lithographic copies would be dropped. The print-on-demand copies would
be copyrighted and would not be in the Federal Depository Library Program.
of Congress Geography and Map Division (LC G&M)
Hebert, the new Chief of the Geography and Map Division at the Library of
Congress spoke to the Council before lunch. John worked in the
Library’s Hispanic Division before moving to Geography and Map. He
announced several staffing changes. Betsy Mangan will be retiring in the
Summer. Betsy has been with the Division for over 30 years. John hopes to
hire an assistant chief and someone to take over the reins of the
cataloging unit. Al Herman retired in the spring. The Division will be
hiring a new Administrative Officer. Currently, the Division is in good
shape as far as staffing—the push for materials in the American
Memory Program has helped.
Division continues to bring in a large number of materials through
purchases, the State Department Program, and the copyright program.
Recently, the Division received a gift including 6 of the known 18 maps by Lafayette’s
cartographer. The Division is starting to make arrangements to acquire maps
summer, LC implimented a new Integrated Library System (ILS)—Endeavor.
It has been a trial at times. NIMA also installed Endeavor, so the two
organizations are working out agreements to share data. While NIMA has
never used the MARC format, they have cataloged each individual sheet of
the various map series. Conversely, LC catalogs using MARC, but has not
individually cataloged the sheets to its various series (numbering over
2,000,000 sheets). Once LC acquires the individual sheet information from
NIMA, they will hire contract workers to bring the records up to LC standards.
National Digital Library Program is entering its 5th year. The
Library is reviewing the Program and deciding whether it should remain in
the departments (like G & M) or consolidated into one system-wide
office. The Division has completed scanning their collection of panoramic
maps of the US,
and continues to add these types of maps as they acquire them. They have
also completely scanned two atlases including one by Ortelius. New
categories include railroads maps, Civil War maps, Revolutionary War maps,
and maps of the Spanish and Portuguese world from before 1600. The maps in
the various categories are being derived from the cartobibliographies
compiled at LC. The Civil War scanning project was begun in November 1999.
The Revolutionary War maps will start soon. Spanish maps will start in the
Fall. The Division entered a contract in 1998 with Sanborn to scan their
maps. The project has been halted due to a dispute over copyright. LC is
allowing Sanborn access to 250,000 maps that are in the public domain, but
Sanborn wants to add a copyright statement to the scanned images. LC feels
that anything made before 1923 is in the public domain. Also, the Division
is currently exploring a cooperative project with the State of Virginia Library and
West Point to scan maps of the
cartographer of the Confederacy. Other proposed scanning projects include
county atlases from the 1800’s, land ownership maps, and maps of Eastern Europe from the late 1800’s. Printed
copies of the scanned maps are available through a company in Seattle — www.museumarchives.com.
John believes that a print out of a panoramic map will cost about $40.
Fitzpatrick has received funding to hire two people in FY 2001 and two more
in FY 2002 to do GIS in the Division for Congress. Essentially, they will
create GIS maps on demand for Congressional members.
Council inquired about the LC Summer Project. John was very interested in
doing it. Despite concerns about the cost of housing, he indicated that LC
would be unable to provide funding toward housing. However, he encouraged
everyone to write letters to him requesting information and expressing
interest in the Summer Program. He indicated the Philip Lee Philips Society
might be able to help.
Division has initiated weekly talks by staff members. The topics are chosen
by the speakers and the talks are intended to build bridges of
understanding within the Division, and to let others know what they are
Imagery and Mapping Agency (NIMA)
Lusby addressed the Council for NIMA. He works in the National/Civil
Agencies Customer Operation Branch. There are Customer Operations liaison
officers and technicians stationed worldwide. NIMA products meet the needs
of civil, national, and law enforcement customers. Their products helped
support the USGS Environmental Crisis Support efforts such as Hurricane
Mitch, and the Colombian earthquake. Working with the Secret Service, NIMA
has supported security efforts during the Papal visit to St. Louis, the Energy Conference in Houston, and the
World Bank Meeting in Washington.
digital products that NIMA has available are on their web site:
agreements with other countries, NIMA will soon be distributing available
topographic maps at a scale of 1:50,000, 1:1000,000, 1:250,000, and Cities
at various scales of the following countries: Vietnam, Cambodia, Laos,
Somalia, Tanzania, Uganda, Bolivia, Dominican Republic, Haiti, Belize,
Honduras, Guatemala, El Salvador, Nicaragua, and Costa Rica. Once printed,
depository libraries who have chosen to receive NIMA topographic maps will
get a full set (or as many as are available) of each country.
summary, Jim made three points: 1) There will be Digital Nautical Charts
(DNCs) which are vector images. These are not yet finished. There is a
replacement for Digital Chart of the World it is the Vector Map Level 0
which consist of four (4) CD-ROMs. 2) There will be a vector map of the
world at Level 1 detail but only of selective countries. 3) NIMA is moving
toward providing foundation-feature data electronically. They want to
provide the data and have others do the hardcopy mapping. The data will be
continuously updated. There are no concrete plans to archive the data, but
they are talking about it. NIMA hopes to phase out printed products by
Marx, Chief of the Census Bureau’s Geography Division, and Tim
Trainor, Chief of the Cartographic Operations Branch spoke to CUAC about
developments at the Census Bureau. They gave the Council a TIGER bookmark
that had lots of useful URLs for Geography Division web sites.
began their talk with new developments for Census 2000. The term Block
Numbering Areas (BNAs) will not be used any more; just Census Tracts and
Census Block Groups, although not all of these have been developed with
local authorities. Formerly, there was a required minimum population of
1000 in order to constitute a Census Designated Place (CDP), but now there
will be no minimum population requirement. CDPs are closely settled and
named, although unincorporated, communities. The Census works with local
governments to decide which blocks make up a CDP. Block numbers will now be
4 digits with no suffix; this style of number will be available first with
the P.L. 94-171 data release shortly before April 2001. Census blocks are
the smallest area of land defined by line features on census maps. ZIP Code
Tabulation Areas (ZCTAs) are approximately the same as USPS ZIP Code
service areas and have been developed to address difficulties in mapping
USPS ZIP Codes. ZIP Codes are assigned to routes or points, and technically
aren’t area features. ZCTAs will be done at the 3-digit level for
large areas that don’t have housing units (because ZIP Codes in these
areas are as yet undefined by the US Postal Service).
contrast to the predominately black and white paper products from 1990 and
earlier, Census 2000 will have an emphasis on electronic map products, in
color, with paper products available on demand. Electronic media will
include the Internet, CD-ROM, and DVD-ROM. Plotter formats will include
Adobe Acrobat Portable Document Format (PDF) and Hewlett Packard Graphic
Language (HPGL). Examples of CDs being produced are the Congressional
District Atlas, Census Mapper, and PL 94-171 Redistricting Data from the
Census 2000 Dress Rehearsal. Digital format has advantages in the areas of
more efficient storage, ease of selecting and choosing a map, and retaining
the ability to print. Census’s standard plotter is an HP DesignJet
1050C, which produces color or black and white output at 600 dots per inch
and includes 80 megabytes of RAM and a 2 gigabyte hard disc. The Acrobat
files will have thumbnails and geographi area names will be searchable.
will still be able to order paper products from the Census Bureau.
Cartographic products will be available a month before the PL 94-171 data
and should cost the same as in 1990 ($5 a sheet for a printed map).
Boundary files in Acrobat (PDF) will be downloadable to the public, but not
the HPGL plotter format; the latter can be purchased on DVD.
of paper products that will be available for purchase are large-format
reference maps, such as Government Unit Block Maps, Census Tract Outline
Maps, and State/County Outline Maps. After 2000, State/County Metro Areas,
Urbanized Areas, and Congressional Districts maps will be available, as
well as Public Use Microdata Sample Products (PUMS). Corner Point Files,
based on map sheet coordinates, will be provided for large format maps
94-171 paper products will be available by March 2001, HPGL files by April,
and Acrobat files in May. The Governmental unit maps will be available on
paper in May 2001, in HPGL in June, and in Acrobat in July. Other reference
maps will follow later in 2001.
those needing to manipulate electronic files, generalized boundary files
will be available from the Census Bureau’s Geography Division
cartographic boundary file web site (http://www.census.gov/geo/www/cob/) in
some standard GIS formats: ArcView shape files, ArcInfo export format
files, and ASCII. The TIGER/Linefile discs will continue to be available as
they have been for those who need to translate street and boundary files
into GIS formats. Files will come with FGDC compliant metadata.
Mueller spoke to the Council concerning USGS issues. The Survey serves a
variety of disciplines including geologic, cartographic (i.e., National
Mapping Division), hydrologic, and biologic. They are moving into the web
in all areas, including data, electronic publications, status graphics,
GNIS, geography, and National Biological Infrastructure. Search and access
tools include GLIS to identify and order materials, and Earth Explorer
(from OHIOVIEW funding that contains Landsat and Corona).
lists will continue to be put online. These will show the version-date
rather than the currentness-date. The version date is the latest date, and
will be in the lower right-hand corner of the paper topographic map. New
editions of the paper indexes will combine map indexes (the green books)
and map lists (the information in the old brown books or white state map
lists) onto one sheet. While, the printed map lists will only show the
version date, the online map lists give both version and currentness dates.
Map reference codes will be added to the index sheet. Maine is the prototype for this series,
with North Carolina
in the works. The Mineral Resources Data System (MRDS) and the Minerals
Availability System/Minerals Industry Location System (MAS/MILS) databases
are available in electronic format on CD-ROM-DDS-52.
Terraserver offers maps on
the web. The DRG’s are available for all of the U.S. except
The DOQ’s are still not complete for the entire U.S.
the Council about a new information program that may be accessed by calling
1-888-ASK-USGS. One of the option buttons on the toll-free number is
"Talk to the USGS Library Information Desk." The new web site (http://ask.usgs.gov) will have
information on water, hazards, and biology.
thematic map series are changing. The "I," "HA," and
"Circum-Pacific" map series will continue to be produced, and be
sent under a single depository number. Other series are complete and the
final numbers are: C-146, OM-227, OC-148, GP-1016, MR-96, GQ-1804. A few
maps in each series are still in progress, and will be sent when completed.
The MF series may be saved but only in electronic form.
continues on the online version of the National Atlas, which may be
viewed at www.nationalatlas.gov/. The project is
progressing with the cooperation of eighteen federal agency partners. Some
new maps include a shaded relief map, and an earthquake map. The
National Atlas has an interactive browser and connects with the TerraServer
which allows patrons to view aspects of a local area.
trends were noted in USGS map production and distribution. There will be
more cooperative partnerships. USGS maps will likely continue not to fall
under copyright. Future revision of the topographic maps will focus on
top-selling quads and on maps produced in cooperation with other agencies.
U.S. Forest Service (USFS)
Banas from the US Forest Service, Washington,
D.C. Office spoke to the
Council about some new mapping activities. Mapping for the Forest Service
historically was done from regional offices. But in 1975, the Forest
Service began to consolidate mapping with the establishment of the Geometronics Service Center
in Salt Lake City.
As technology has evolved the Center has become increasinly involved in
geospatial activities: providing geospatial data, services and training in
addition to traditional mapping. In 1999 Geometronics Service
Center was renamed
the Geospatial Service and Technology Center (GSTC), to better reflect its
production of the "Single edition" series of maps continues.
These are produced to the specifications of the USGS 1:24,000 scale
topographic quadrangles with Forest Service information as well. Several
years ago, the Forest Service entered into an agreement with USGS to
produce, in accordance with USGS standards, the quads covering the Forests.
Consequently, the Forest Service is in the process of updating a large
number of topo maps, and plans to keep their revision cycle on a tighter
schedule than would otherwise be possible if USGS were responsible for
their update. Five years is the ideal but realistically it can be as much
as 15 to 20 years. Quads in areas of frequent change are revised more
recently, the Forest Visitors' Maps have been available for purchase only
from the individual forests themselves. But, the Service has entered into
an agreement with USGS such that USGS will sell and distribute Forest
Visitor Maps through their vendor network for participating Forests.
October 1999, President Clinton called a halt to all construction of Roads
in unroaded Forest areas. This (the Roadless
Initiative) is a conservation effort to protect endangered species and
promote biological diversity. An environmental impact statement will be
done on 54 million acres. GIS has been an essential tool in this process.
Numerous product-specific maps have been generated which display
information from a variety of geospatial and tabular files. The data
provides information regarding inventory of roadless areas, road status,
fire risk, forest health. These can be viewed at: www.roadless.fs.fed.us.
Park Service (NPS)
Patterson from the National Park Service Division of Publications at the Harpers Ferry Center spoke to the Council
regarding mapping of the National Parks. Lands under Park Service
stewardship cover most States and Territories, including Alaska, Hawaii, American Samoa, Guam,
the Virgin Islands, and Puerto
Rico. The Harpers
staff of four cartographers provide visitor-orientation mapping for the 379
parks in the system. The cartographic program at Harpers Ferry Center
is unique among Federal agencies for its strong emphasis on graphic design.
National Park Service web site receives approximately 850,000 hits per day.
Within that site, the Harpers
web site is the 10th most popular web site in the NPS. There were 4.7
million hits on the Harpers Ferry site
are approximately 500 maps in the Division of Publications inventory, 99%
of which are digitized. Of the digital inventory, 80% are on the web. The
remaining 20% are still waiting to be printed before they are placed on the
web. Vector map files are available in both Adobe Acrobat (PDF) format and
Adobe Illustrator (AI) format. With the release of Adobe Illustrator 9.0,
maps will be posted in PDF format only, since the PDF and AI formats will
merge. Shaded relief images, which are used as placed art backgrounds
within vector maps, are published on the web only in gray scale. Well over
100 shaded reliefs are loaded on the web page as 200 dpi JPEGs. There are
no plans to scan historic park maps.
presented new maps of Mt. Rainier; Crater Lake; Channel Islands (with
digitally-generated bathymetry); Buck Island Reef in the Virgin Islands (he
noted that it was a challenge to show the reef bottom with traditional
cartographic methods, so they incorporated aerial photography); an oblique
view of the Grand Canyon; California Trail; a guide to Fort Larned, KS
(using 3D technology for the landscape details, including buildings and
trees); and Fort Davis, Texas.